Discussion about this post

User's avatar
JasonT's avatar

Profanity is too often a substitute for creativity.

Expand full comment
Madame Z's avatar

Honestly, excessive profanity makes me close the book. I am inclined towards more traditional aesthetics, so most books published after 1962 (the year Faulkner died) do not appeal to me. If there are too many f-bombs in a mere 20-pages, I know the novel will become tedious to me. Sometimes, I think it is a matter of 'just because you can, doesn't mean you should'. Hemingway portrayed soldiers, sailors, everyday-men, without needing to use profanity (he couldn't, as it was unacceptable in his time)--however, I think that we should see an opportunity to be more creative by 'censoring ourselves'. I think Hemingway actually preserved the Stoic and sparse quality of his prose by removing profanity therefrom. There are more clever ways to express horrific things without being explicit. Say something by not saying it. etc.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts